Monday, January 19, 2009

More subjective shit - Nice guys and coming last

Ah! so through my meanderings and random stopping by's through the blogosphere i came across quite a thought provoking item done by Papare Boy (sorry, i cant seem to get that little line above the 'e'). I of course, use the word 'shit' here merely to quantify, and not to degrade. Think of it as if i was saying 'stuff' instead and not 'shit'. As a matter of fact, i could have just gone and changed it to 'stuff' and saved myself all the trouble of explanation but i am in a rambly sort of mood, and will indulge myself.

So Nice Guys, do they really finish last? several ladies opined on the topic among them the Goddess and Makuluwo who by her own admission (read, blog URL) is slightly mad (:p - sry, couldn resist doing my own tame MoB). Makuluwo raised quite an interesting point when she said "I think the definition of NICE, goddessofvileness, is always relative!"

Hmmm.. okay, now before we delve into this little study of ameteur sociology, i suggest you read the full thing along with the whole riveting discussion which can be found here.  If you're interested enough that is, otherwise stick around here lets see what we can dig up.

All right, so first of all what i do is a google the term 'nice guys finish last' right? and obviously i straightaway head into wiki. dont even know why i google most stuff anymore, i inevitably go into wiki from the search results.

One main thing we've got to get clear. We are strictly talking about matters closer to the libido and heart here. Since it appears that it really doesn't matter what kind of man you are for the whole world to accept you, the main problem area seems to appear when it comes to being accepeted by the oposite sex.

First, what the devil is a nice guy? is he, as Papare Boy postulates, someone who doesn't beat you over the head when you mess with the remote? With all due respect to PB however, i think expertise lies with the infe superior sex (on the topic) so why dont we go straight to the source?

Actually, Harold and Millhausen (1998) have already done this so lets just save ourselves the trouble and have a look at their findings shall we?

They found that women associate different qualities with the "nice guy" label:

"Some women offered flattering interpretations of the nice guy, characterizing him as committed, caring, and respectful of women.

Some women, however, emphasized more negative aspects, considering the nice guy to be boring, lacking confidence, and unattractive."

There is also a negative phenomenon associated with the "nice girl" in the same respect. She may be considered to be a prude, boring and submissive. (this is not really relevant to the topic so lets just disregard this)

The bad boys were also divided into two categories, "as either confident, attractive, sexy, and exciting or as manipulative, unfaithful, disrespectful of women, and interested only in sex."

Hmmm so according to Harold and Millhausen basically you can look at nice guys in one of two ways. Positively or negatively. Am i safe if i say that? no arguments there? So if you're 'committed, caring, and respectful of women' it makes you nice and if you are 'boring, lacking confidence, and unattractive' well IMO that just makes you a wimp.

And if you are confident, attractive, sexy, and exciting that makes you Bad (but bad like Russel Crowe) whilst if you're manipulative, unfaithful, disrespectful of women, and interested only in sex that also makes you bad but this time somewhere along the lines of Commodus (Joaquin Pheonix in Gladiator) or maybe Jack (the Ripper).

So women like nice guys (lets call them honorable guys) but dont like wimps. Women also like heroic chaps but also dislike the more perverted variety. Simple as that. You have to be nice but you cant be a wimp. You've gotta be bad, but you cant be an asshole.

There we go, problem solved.

I think it will be a while till even i come to terms with the magnitude of it all. For what we have accomplished here boys and girls is nothing short of phenomenal. It is the answer to the age old question that has baffled all men since Adam, ever since he discovered that part of his rib was missing and that he was no longer alone up there. The perplexing conundrum (not the blog) that all men inevitably think of when they gaze at the stars or when they look out the window or when they eat, sleep, wake up,jog, work, study etc. What do women really want?

And ladies, dont think that this day is no less important to you, because through empirical analysis you have finally been shown what you really want as well. Because if there's one thing we guys have instinctively known since the beginning of time is that; while we have no clue as to what women want, women, have even less of an idea about the whole thing.

So start thinkng ladies. You know what you want now. Just go out there and get it. Im right here. hyok.

*disclaimer - this post was written on a lazy monday afternoon, so by default, is justified in all its implications. And that includes the marginal meaninglessness of this 'disclaimer'.

32 Comments:

Sabby said...

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure this out but I am gonna state it anyway...

Nice guy = a guy who gives lots lots LOTS lots lots lots LOTS of attention! =)

(My definition of nice guy anyway) =D

TheWhacksteR said...

er hello? did you not read the immutable proof? that may be what a nice guy is to you but the guy you WANT is nice and bad in a good way at the same time!

Sabby said...

You men tend to complicate your lives wayyyyyy too much. And then you call us complex.

A guy is deemed to be nice if he gives us hand on foot attention and lots of love as well as not being a mama's boy and a wuss. It's plenty simple you see.

Or is it?

Muhahahahh!

TheWhacksteR said...

A guy is deemed to be nice if he gives us hand on foot attention and lots of love as well as not being a mama's boy and a wuss

Hey i know someone who fits that description! his name is Hannibal Lecter. :D interested?

Sabby said...

You know Mr Lector?!
Is your relationship-mentor then?

*smiles like an angel*

Sabby said...

he*

TheWhacksteR said...

maybe *slyly hides the fact that he is trying to get something out of sabby*

do you like, eat human flesh?

Sabby said...

Perhaps.
Just FYI, if you like have a date planned...I like me meat well done, ye? =D

Anonymous said...

eat my genitals you bastard!

TheWhacksteR said...

Sabby - hmmm *imagines some nice gormet ghernitalis capariabis under a starlit balcony* i'll keep that in mind :D

Anon - let me get back to you on that

Gehan said...

i was going to write somethin about the post, but then i read this pointless ramble abt hannibal lecter in the comments and now i dunno wat to say...


im sorry dude, as legendary as ur discovery is, i have a feelin tat ppl are gnna rem jan 19th for martin luther king day rather than for.. err.. whacksters day? :D

Anonymous said...

Haha... why is bn 'nice' so complicated? *sigh*

Life is tough :P

Unknown said...

LOL I want a nice guy :(
Heck, right now any guy who meets my requirements would do. :P

Anonymous said...

Nice Guy checklist :P

Average Joe said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Paparé Boy said...

@Sabby - Wouldn't you be bored with a guy who fits your definition of "nice"?

I mean surely a guy who gives you lots^7 (I counted :p) attention is bound to get in the way of your "independence" (the alleged lack of which you fairer sex people love to complain about), yeah? :)

Anonymous said...

So have we reached a conclusion yet?

Sabby said...

PB: True that.
But honestly, doesn't it always come back down to attention?! Someone whose: "committed, caring, and respectful of women" are all linked to paying attention. So in the end, all women want is a whole lotta attention. So I just basically cut the BS and various synonyms when I said what I said.

Plus, women tend to complain about everything, be it lack of independence or space or 'own time' or whatever else you may call it. That's just how we function. If it's not one thing, it's another. So that doesn't really count.

I might be happily chewing on my own foot here but I am just stating it based on my POV and not speaking for other women.

In the end, we (or rather, I) am happy as long as I get my 'nice guy's' attention.

Just Me said...

All I know is the percentage of nice guys is decreasing. I don't know how or why, all I know is I don't know many. But of the handful I do know, I suppose your definition of a nice guy stands.

PS: You forgot adorably sweet!

Makuluwo said...

Haha! Enthralling little synopsis, Whackster! And I appreciate the 'mad' reference, you flatterer, you. ;)

ANYhooo, first off, boys, I really, really offer y'all my deepest sympathies. Because honestly speaking, most women are so bloody confusing and complicated on matters of WHAT THEY WANT from a guy. And I applaud any of you poor blokes for ever figuring out what it is.

As for me, I'm not most women. If you're funny, have a different POV from the boring masses, and not a complete arsehole, chances are we'll get along fine.

Now, nice guys and bad guys. Let us be reminded that these 2 are stereotypes. Personally, stereotypes (of both extremes) are boring and predictable.

Plausible theories on the subject:
The stereotypical 'nice guy' is sweet and caring and loving, girls either like him for this reason or hate him for being too mellow and amicable in his nature.

The stereotypical 'bad guy' is a reckless jerk with many suitors and who likes to live on the edge, girls either hate him for his disrespectful playboy-ness, or see him as an interestingly difficult challenge to conquer.

Comprehende?
But I think, in terms of serious lasting relationships, most women are inclined towards men who hold more qualities of the stereotypical 'nice guy' than the 'bad guy'.

Paparé Boy said...

@The Celestial Dream - You saying nice guys are a dying breed? If that is indeed the case then who's fault will that be now, eh? ;)

Aren't women the very reason why phrases like "nice guys finish last" are here to begin with? :D

Just kidding, Sabby, don't kill me. :p

Makuluwo said...

:P I think 'nice guys finish last' is a 'unisex' phrase, no?
Basically, boys and girls who don't act fast enough in this tricky little dog-eat-dog world, finish last.

Anonymous said...

Wow...that's a lot of wonderfully random comments:)

I think being a nice asshole is the key...a challenge but walk a fine line on the attentiveness.

On a personal level, it seems that girls who are treated like crap, especially if they have self-esteem issues...tend to go for the bad boys who treat them like crap.

Nice guys maybe a dying breed, but it seems so are normal, well adjusted girls:D

Sabby said...

Whackster, you have started a riot =)

Being nice comes so easy. It's funny how debatable being so is, though.

As N says, I guess being a 'Nice asshole' is the next big thing. =)

pissu perera said...

whackster, dude, you have way too much time on your hands :p

T said...

i think N is pretty much right on. "nice assholes".. i usually tend to go for that type.

but whackster, while this is true: "while we have no clue as to what women want, women, have even less of an idea about the whole thing."
the problem is that you boys are yet to figure that out en masse.

TheWhacksteR said...

Woah! riot is right! hmmm now where shall we start?

Gehan -i was think more like 'the greatest mystery solved! day ?

Goddess - bein a goddess cant be all that great then. so much for greener grass;)

Hijinx - and what ARE your requirements ma'am i am dying to know.

Goddess - Nice (check), wimp (out), Bad (check), perv (out).

seee, simple.

PB - 'Wouldn't you be bored..' ah therein lies another eternal mystey of women, getting exactly whet they want and getting bored with it. more proof that they should stop stereotyping us.

Sabby - 'women tend to complain about everything....''that doesn't really count...' HOW can it not count?

and as for attention, how much attention do you need? like obsessive parental attention? :)


Celestial - Finally! a lady agrees :) adorably sweet? hmmm maybe a nice/bad guy with a teddy bear as a gift.

Makuluwo - aww.. anytime you crazy loon you. and

"I think 'nice guys finish last' is a 'unisex' phrase, no?"

lady, you've practically bowled me over with your philosophical insight! this is definitely the quote of the post!

Sabby - yes i can see that. how about that meal then :)

PP - hmmm... may be i should look for a more productive mode of output?

Jerry said...

Okay everyone, I am here to deliver my verdict on this engrossing subject.

Cows.

That's what most people are. They are confused, irritating and ask for things they don't want. Didn't we already land on the conclusion that N brought up? A nice asshole. A person who isn't a wimp, but also is not a cold hearted SOB.


Carry on. The all knowing teenager has passed on his wisdom to you lesser mortals.

Anonymous said...

I think my version of what a nice guy is has been described aptly in my last post, don't you think? ;-)

TheWhacksteR said...

N - you are right, we tend to get waaay too intimidated by what we percieve women to want. Serious social education problem there N,little do we know that women have no requirements whatsoever. it just a question of the right deer getting stuck in fron of the right headlight :D

looks like we've coined a term then

'Nice Assholes'

isnt that (or did it use to be) an oxymoron?


Jerry - O Thank you knowing teenager. we all all waiting for more of your post adolescent intellectual inputs..

you're right though. Cows. hmmm

TMS - hmmm... and an apt description of a 'niiice' girl too i think :D

Makuluwo said...

lol! I HAVE?! Ok if that isn't some surreptitiously sarcastic remark, *tips hat* much obliged. :P

TheWhacksteR said...

N - I think being a nice asshole is the key...a challenge but walk a fine line on the attentiveness.

Nice asshole again eh lol. just found out a didnt reply to your comment earlier! your right ive discovered that too. women with self esteem issues tend to pursue guys with the same.

T - forgive me T ive addressed you as N in my orevious comment :0 damn, must have been in the confusion of the aftermath (N's influence)

Makuluwo - *graciously nods* eagerly awaiting more brilliant one liners!